
Following an earlier preliminary injunction issued on September 14, 2026, which temporarily postponed the rule’s implementation, Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV granted summary judgment in favor of a coalition of higher education associations and labor unions in Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, et al. v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, et al. (Case No. 1:26-cv-13799-FDS).
Background and Legal Context
Published on July 17, 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 44976), the DHS Final Rule aimed to eliminate the decades-old duration of status policy, which permits F, J, and I nonimmigrants to remain in the United States for as long as they maintain compliance with the terms of their admission and academic or exchange programs. Under the invalidated rule, these visa holders would have been admitted for a fixed time period and required to apply for formal extensions of stay to complete their programs. The rule also placed strict limitations on academic mobility, restricting students from changing academic concentrations, pursuing joint degrees, or enrolling in programs at the same or lower educational level as a previously completed degree.
In vacating the rule under the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. § 706), the Court held that the regulation was both arbitrary and capricious and contrary to statutory authority. Specifically, the Court determined that:
- Inadequate Cost-Benefit and Alternative Analysis: DHS failed to properly weigh the substantial burdens of the rule against its purported fraud and national security rationales. Notably, the agency failed to consider less burdensome alternatives, such as utilizing and enhancing existing oversight tools within the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS).
- Statutory Overreach: By prohibiting bona fide students from pursuing legitimate academic pathways—such as joint graduate degrees, extended Ph.D. programs, or sequential degrees at the same level—DHS exceeded its statutory authority under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(F). The Court emphasized that executive authority to set conditions of stay must remain reasonably related to the statutory purpose of permitting and encouraging educational opportunities in the United States.
- Vacatur as the Appropriate Remedy: Rejecting DHS’s request to remand the rule without vacatur, the Court concluded that vacating the rule entirely would not cause disruption because the Final Rule had never taken effect and the existing regulatory framework has operated for decades.
Practical Implications for Visa Holders and Institutions
Because the Final Rule is vacated in its entirety, the status quo remains intact:
- Duration of Status Remains in Effect: F, J, and I nonimmigrants will continue to be admitted for the duration of their authorized programs rather than a fixed expiration date.
- No New Extension Filings Required: Students, scholars, and foreign media representatives do not need to file additional extension of stay applications with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) solely due to a fixed four-year or program-length cap.
- Academic Flexibility Preserved: International students retain the ability to change majors, pursue dual or joint degrees, and enroll in sequential programs at the same or different academic levels in accordance with existing Student and Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP) guidelines.
Next Steps
While the District Court’s ruling provides immediate relief and stability, the government has an active interlocutory appeal pending before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit regarding the earlier preliminary injunction and may appeal this final summary judgment order.
- Maintain Standard Compliance: F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors, and I visa holders should continue adhering to all existing SEVIS reporting, enrollment, and program maintenance requirements.
- Coordinate with Institutional Officials: Students and researchers planning program extensions, degree level changes, or transfers should continue working directly with their Designated School Officials (DSOs) or Responsible Officers (ROs) under current SEVP and Department of State procedures.
- Monitor Appellate Developments: Educational institutions, sponsors, and affected foreign nationals should stay informed regarding potential First Circuit appellate proceedings or future regulatory proposals from DHS.
INLG continues to monitor federal litigation and regulatory developments affecting international students, scholars, and media professionals. For case-specific guidance or questions regarding nonimmigrant status maintenance, please contact INLG directly.
